 |
Dilemma PodcastAuthor: Jay Shapiro
Solving the problems of what to do next with some of today's top thinkers and writers. Hosted by Jay Shapiro. Language: en Genres: Philosophy, Society & Culture Contact email: Get it Feed URL: Get it iTunes ID: Get it |
Listen Now...
This Rabbi Explains How How Zionism Turned Jews Into Symbolic Human Shields | Yaakov Shapiro
Wednesday, 22 April, 2026
In this long-form conversation, I sit down with Rabbi Yaakov Shapiro—one of the most outspoken anti-Zionist ultra-Orthodox rabbis—to explore one of the most misunderstood questions in modern politics: what is the relationship between Judaism and Zionism? Raised in suburban American Conservative Judaism with Israeli flags on the bimah, Hebrew school, bar mitzvahs, and an unspoken expectation to support Israel, I wanted to understand what exactly I inherited—and whether it had anything to do with Judaism as a religion at all.We begin with my own family story: my great-great-grandfather, a Satmar Jew in Hungary, was murdered in Auschwitz, while his daughter had left that world decades earlier for America. A few generations later, I inherited a version of Jewish identity shaped less by theology than by Holocaust memory and Zionist politics. Rabbi Shapiro argues that Zionism fundamentally transformed Judaism from a religion of covenant, law, and exile into a political nationalism—and in doing so, created deep moral and philosophical confusion for Jews like me who never believed in the theology but were still expected to defend the state of Israel.From the Holocaust and 1967 to female rabbis, the orange on the Seder plate, chosenness, antisemitism, and whether Judaism is a religion or an ethnicity, this conversation goes far beyond headlines. We discuss whether Zionism is a form of idolatry, why many religious Jews see Israel as a theological violation, and why the phrase “let Judaism be a religion and let Israel be a foreign country” might be the clearest way to understand the crisis. A serious philosophical conversation about faith, identity, history, and the moral catastrophe of Zionism... for the world... and for Judaism.00:00 Coming Up...01:46 Intro My Family Story: Satmar Roots, Auschwitz, and America11:27 My Opening Question: What Did I Actually Get Growing Up?21:13 What Do I Have To Do To Be A Jew?32:14 Jabotinsky and the Zionist Rejection of the “Exile Jew”39:19 I Didn’t Get Judaism—I Got Israel42:11 “Let Judaism Be a Religion, Let Israel Be a Country” Rabbi Shapiro’s Definition of Zionism57:06 Chosen People, Christians, and Jewish Identity01:04:00 Who Gets to Define Who Is a Jew?01:10:29 Are Religious Zionists Actually Religious?01:19:21 Holocaust Identity and Postwar American Judaism01:21:18 Moral Philosophy vs Divine Command01:27:12 Different Roads, Same Conclusion: Zionism Is Wrong01:44:18 The Best Zionist Argument: The Fear of Another Holocaust01:51:24 Would You Go Quietly? Zionists Killing Jews: The Case of Jacob de Haan01:55:48 1967 and the Zionist Transformation of American Judaism01:58:18 Final Thoughts: Obligation, Opportunity, and Another RoundBECOME A MEMBER - MONTHLY MEMBERS ONLY LIVESTREAM https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC5NIku35U9thGG9WBJjE0sw/joinFor more from Jay visit whatjaythinks.com
