![]() |
Movie HighLowAuthor: Movie HighLow Movie Reviews & Film Analysis
Movie HighLow is a movie review and film analysis podcast about the best, worst, and weirdest movies cinema has to offer. Each episode, we revisit iconic films, cult classics, Hollywood disasters, bad movie masterpieces, and misunderstood flops to find the HIGHS, the LOWS, and the moments that deserve a second look. Some movies are great. Some are terrible. Some are both. From iconic classics to fascinating disasters, were here to figure out why. Film analysis Movie breakdowns Movie reviews High vs Low Film podcast Language: en Genres: Arts, Film Reviews, TV & Film, Visual Arts Contact email: Get it Feed URL: Get it iTunes ID: Get it Trailer: |
Listen Now...
SCENT OF A WOMAN (1992) | Frank Was in the Dark Before He Went Blind (High)
Episode 35
Thursday, 19 November, 2026
We went High on Scent of a Woman (1992), and we’re ready to defend a movie that has developed a surprisingly complicated reputation. Is Al Pacino going completely over the top? Absolutely. Is Colonel Frank Slade an arrogant, foul-mouthed, womanizing asshole? Without question. Does Martin Brest’s movie occasionally confuse emotional intensity with emotional subtlety? Sure. But none of that means the movie doesn't work. Our central argument is that Frank Slade isn't miserable because he's blind. He was miserable long before he lost his sight. His blindness didn't destroy a wonderful life. It left him with fewer places to hide from the person he'd already become. When Frank screams, "I'm in the dark here," he's not just talking about his vision. He's talking about his soul. And what makes Scent of a Woman such a great movie isn't that a sweet young man magically fixes a broken older one. It's that two people with completely different problems discover they have exactly what the other needs. In this episode of Movie HighLow, we revisit Scent of a Woman, directed by Martin Brest and released in 1992, starring Al Pacino as Lieutenant Colonel Frank Slade and Chris O'Donnell as Charlie Simms. Pacino won his first Academy Award for Best Actor for this performance, and we spend a lot of time discussing whether the movie, the performance, and that Oscar have aged as poorly as some critics suggest. Charlie is a scholarship student at the prestigious Baird School, where wealthy students can afford to treat consequences like an inconvenience their parents will eventually solve. After witnessing a prank on the school's headmaster, Charlie faces a choice: identify the students responsible or jeopardize his own future. Meanwhile, Charlie takes a Thanksgiving job looking after Frank Slade, a blind, retired Army lieutenant colonel who has absolutely no intention of spending the holiday sitting at home. Instead, Frank drags him to New York City for an expensive weekend involving fine dining, beautiful women, a tango, a Ferrari, and a deeply disturbing final item on his itinerary: a loaded .45. The biggest High is Al Pacino's performance, and we think its excess is completely justified by the character. Frank has spent his life commanding attention, intimidating people, shocking everyone around him, and turning every conversation into a performance. His personality is enormous because it's the only weapon he believes he has left. The movie doesn't ask us to approve of Frank's behavior. It asks us to understand it. That's what makes the Thanksgiving dinner scene so important. When Frank visits his brother's family, we can immediately sense the history. This isn't the first holiday he's ruined. His nephew Randy, played by Bradley Whitford, finally starts tearing into him, revealing the ridiculous, self-inflicted circumstances behind Frank's blindness. Frank was already bitter and angry about his life. Then, after drinking too much, he tried to show off by juggling grenades and ended up destroying his own future. That story changes everything about how we understand him. Frank wasn't a good man who had something terrible happen to him. He was a self-destructive man who eventually suffered the consequences of his own behavior. And when Randy turns his cruelty toward Charlie, something important happens: Charlie stands up for Frank. For perhaps the first time in a long time, Frank experiences someone defending him without being asked. We also spend time defending Chris O'Donnell's performance. Charlie may seem like the innocent, wide-eyed kid standing beside a legendary actor working at maximum volume, but that contrast is essential. Charlie doesn't need to learn right from wrong. He already knows the right thing to do. His problem is that he's terrified of what doing it might cost him. Frank, meanwhile, has all the confidence in the world and absolutely nothing left that he believes is worth standing up for. That's the movie. One of our favorite scenes is the famous Scent of a Woman tango scene. We talk about how the dance works on several levels. Frank approaches a young woman who has always wanted to learn the tango, and for a few minutes, he creates a beautiful experience for someone instead of making their life more difficult. He's also teaching Charlie something about confidence: approach life, don't apologize for taking up space, and when you get tangled up, keep moving. But the tango isn't just about Frank teaching someone else. Because he's blind and his partner doesn't know the steps, the dance requires both people to trust each other. He guides her, and she guides him. Then comes the Ferrari test-drive scene, which takes the same idea and pushes it toward disaster. Where the tango represents Frank's grace, the Ferrari represents his recklessness. Charlie wants to delay Frank's suicide plan, so he finds something that might make him feel alive again. Frank gets behind the wheel because he desperately wants to experience control, speed, danger, and independence one more time. Once again, the experience only works because two people trust each other. And once the ride ends, the reality of Frank's situation comes crashing back. The hotel room suicide confrontation might be the movie's most powerful scene. Frank is ready to end his life, and Charlie refuses to leave him alone. Suddenly, the lessons Frank has spent the weekend teaching Charlie come right back at him. Charlie finally finds the confidence to stand his ground, even when he's terrified. He doesn't cure Frank's depression or somehow erase years of self-hatred. He simply gives him a reason to reconsider what happens next. That distinction is what makes the scene work. The biggest debate of the episode is the famous Baird School disciplinary hearing, where Frank delivers his explosive speech defending Charlie. We know the criticisms. The speech is theatrical, sentimental, melodramatic, and very, very loud. But we think it earns every decibel. Headmaster Trask has turned a school disciplinary matter into a public spectacle designed to humiliate Charlie and force him to betray his principles. Frank recognizes the performance for what it is and decides to fight theater with theater. For the entire movie, Frank has used his enormous personality to dominate people for his own benefit. At Baird, he finally uses that same force to defend someone who deserves it. That's his redemption. He doesn't become a different person. He finally does something worthwhile with the person he already is. We do have some Lows. The movie is too long, and we think a tighter edit could have removed 15 to 20 minutes without sacrificing its emotional impact. The Park Avenue sequence following the Ferrari scene feels unnecessary, and even the famous Baird speech makes its point before Pacino finishes making it. We also question Frank's borderline supernatural ability to identify every perfume, physical feature, and woman within smelling distance. The man is blind. He's not Daredevil. But subtlety isn't the only measure of emotional honesty. Scent of a Woman is a High because Frank and Charlie don't magically fix each other. Frank teaches Charlie to find his courage. Charlie teaches Frank that tomorrow might still be worth experiencing. One man learns how to stand up for what he believes in. The other finally finds something worth standing up for. Hoo-ah Scent of a Woman 1992 movie review Martin Brest's Scent of a Woman Al Pacino as Colonel Frank Slade Chris O'Donnell as Charlie Simms Al Pacino's Best Actor Oscar win Scent of a Woman ending explained The meaning of "I'm in the dark here" Frank Slade's blindness and backstory Scent of a Woman Thanksgiving dinner scene Bradley Whitford as Randy Slade Scent of a Woman tango scene explained Al Pacino's Ferrari driving scene Scent of a Woman hotel suicide scene Scent of a Woman Baird School speech Frank Slade's redemption arc Charlie Simms and moral integrity Why Scent of a Woman deserves its reputation Has Scent of a Woman aged well? Al Pacino's over-the-top performance Scent of a Woman movie highs and lows













